Total: 1
A wide range of numerical and semi-analytical approaches has been developed for optical modeling of photonic-crystal surface-emitting lasers (PCSELs). However, a systematic framework for comparing their predictive capabilities and identifying their respective validity limits remains largely unexplored. In this work, we introduce a comparative methodology in which four representative methods - including rigorous numerical and effective-index-based approaches - are analyzed and partially hybridized within a coupled-wave-theory framework. Using single-lattice and double-lattice PCSELs as representative models, we demonstrate that this approach not only reveals fundamental differences between predictions of rigorous numerical methods and the coupled-wave-theory framework, but also captures a qualitative phase transition and a symmetry-broken phase of quasi-bound states in the continuum (quasi-BICs) relevant for laser operation.